Consonance, register and the low-interval limit
Why the same interval can be smooth on one sound and harsh on another, and how low you can voice a chord.
3.2 Consonance depends on the sound
Two notes sound rough when their partials are close in frequency but not identical, because they beat against each other. Psychoacoustic research (Plomp and Levelt in 1965, later William Sethares) showed that perceived dissonance comes largely from this beating between partials, more than from the interval as an abstract ratio.
That has two practical consequences:
The sound changes which intervals are dissonant. A minor 2nd between two sines is a gentle shimmer. Between two saws it is harsh, because every pair of harmonics clashes as well.
The register changes which intervals are dissonant. The ear’s frequency resolution is coarser in the low range, so partials a minor 3rd apart in the bass clash about as much as partials a semitone apart do higher up.
The low-interval limit
This is why 3rds turn to mud low down. A working guide:
| Range | Roughly | What works |
|---|---|---|
| Above about 260 Hz | Above C3 (middle C) | Any interval, including clusters on soft sounds |
| 130 to 260 Hz | C2 to C3 | Thirds and sixths start to thicken; use open voicings |
| 65 to 130 Hz | C1 to C2 | Fifths and octaves only |
| Below about 65 Hz | Below C1 | One note at a time |