The seam and rotation
The chord change you hear every cycle, and why the same four chords can sound like two different songs.
5.2 The seam and rotation
In a loop, the change from the last chord back to the first is heard every cycle, so it is the most important change in the progression. A weak seam makes a good loop sound like it is stalling once every bar or two.
Rotation is free variation. I – V – vi – IV and vi – IV – I – V use the same four chords, but a different chord is home. The first sounds like a pop anthem; the second sounds like the same anthem with a minor heart. Before deciding a four-chord loop doesn’t work, try it from all four starting points. The 5.3 table shows the same idea from the other side: vi – IV – I – V in C major and i – bVI – bIII – bVII in A minor are the same four chords, Am F C G. Which one sounds like home depends on what the bass, the melody and the downbeat emphasise.
Tonic substitution gives the second half of a phrase somewhere new to go. The vi and iii chords each share two notes with I, so either can stand in for home; in minor, bIII shares two notes with i. In an eight-bar phrase, start bar 5 on vi instead of I: C – F – G – F becomes Am – F – G – F. The loop changes without leaving the key, and the return to I at bar 9 lands with more weight.