Rhythm, phrase structure and development
Writing the rhythm first, shaping a phrase, and keeping a hook fresh by changing one thing at a time.
7.4 Rhythm and space
Chapter 6 introduced writing rhythm before pitch. For melodies the method is the same: tap or program the rhythm on one note, loop it over the drums, then choose the pitches.
Two or three rhythm cells are enough. A rhythm cell is a short rhythmic pattern, usually a beat or two long. A melody with a new one in every bar is hard to remember. Reusing one rhythm with different pitches gives variety without losing the listener.
Rests are part of the hook. Space lets the listener take in the idea, and it leaves room for another part to answer (7.5).
Where the phrase starts matters. Starting on the downbeat sounds stable and declarative. Starting just before it (a pickup) or just after it sounds conversational and pushes forward (Chapter 2, 2.2).
Note length is rhythm too. Changing a line from 16th notes to dotted 8ths, or from staccato to legato, changes its groove even with the same onsets.
7.5 Phrase structure and development
A hook needs a shape at the phrase level as well as the note level. Three forms cover most electronic hooks:
Question and answer (2 + 2 bars). The question ends away from home: on the 2nd, 5th or 7th degree, or on a chord tone that isn’t the root. The answer ends on the tonic or the root of the chord. Chapter 1’s 2-bar call and response is the same idea at a smaller scale.
The sentence (1 + 1 + 2 bars). A one-bar idea, the same idea repeated or varied, then a two-bar continuation that moves faster and closes. Classical theory calls this a sentence. It is common in pop and dance hooks because it states the idea twice before developing it.
A A A B (Chapter 1). Three repeats and a different ending; the default for loops.
Development is what keeps a hook from going stale across a track. Each device changes one thing and keeps the rest:
| Device | What stays | What changes |
|---|---|---|
| Exact repeat | Everything | Nothing; use for the first two statements |
| Rhythmic repeat | Rhythm | The pitches |
| Sequence | Shape and rhythm | The starting note (the whole figure moves up or down) |
| Changed ending | The first half | The last one or two notes |
| Fragmentation | The last part of the idea | Its length; only that fragment repeats |
| Inversion | Rhythm | The direction of every interval |
Extending a 2-bar idea to 8 bars. Copy it to bars 3–4 and change only the ending, so that the answer lands on a stable chord tone but not yet on the tonic. Then copy the 4 bars to bars 5–8 and change the last ending again, this time resolving to the tonic. One or two changed notes are usually enough each time.