Tension, release and judging a loop
How to build and release tension with the levers from 1.2, whatever the chords are doing, and four tests for whether a loop will last.
1.6 Tension and release beyond the chords
In a song, tension usually comes from the dominant chord and release from the tonic. Loop music builds the same arc out of the parameters in 1.2.
Tension here means expectation: the listener notices that something is missing or about to change, and waits for it. Release is the moment it arrives.
None of the devices below needs the harmony to stand still. Over a moving progression they work just as well, and the chords add tension of their own on top: a build that stops on an unresolved chord makes the return to the tonic on the drop feel like a release (Chapter 5 and Chapter 8).
In dance music, tension and release happen at three scales at once.
Three scales of tension
The beat. Sidechain compression ducks the bass or pad on every kick and lets it swell back before the next one. Each beat becomes a tiny build and release, which is a large part of why house and EDM pump. Overdo it and the track stops pumping and starts to sound seasick.
The phrase. The turnaround bar at the end of an 8-bar phrase holds something back, and bar 1 of the next phrase gives it back (1.4).
The section. A build of 8 or 16 bars ends in a drop. This is what most producers mean by tension and release, and it’s what the rest of this section is about. Chapter 8 places builds and drops in a whole track.
Ways to build tension
Remove the foundation. Taking out the kick or the bass is the strongest tension device in dance music. The body notices before the brain does, and waits for it to come back.
Increase subdivision. Hats from 8ths to 16ths, snare rolls from quarter notes to 16ths, arps doubling their rate.
Open the filter or add drive. Brightness reads as rising energy.
Raise the register. Move a riff up an octave, or let a sustained pitch rise slowly.
Hold a pedal against moving parts. The longer the bass refuses to move, the bigger its eventual move feels.
Withhold the expected. Skip the downbeat of bar 1 of a phrase, or repeat the turnaround bar twice.
Increase the wet signal. Rising reverb or delay feedback blurs the groove and makes the listener want it back in focus.
None of these needs the stock white-noise riser. It works, but it sounds the same in every track. Almost any sound can become a riser, for example a resampled pad pitched up or a delay throw with rising feedback.
Stacking devices into a build
A build rarely relies on one device. It stacks them, adding a new one every few bars while keeping the ones before, so the tension keeps rising. Here is a common 16-bar shape:
| Bars | What changes | Device |
|---|---|---|
| 1–4 | The bass drops out; the kick keeps going | Remove the foundation (half of it) |
| 5–8 | Claps on every beat; the chord filter starts to open | Increase subdivision; open the filter |
| 9–12 | Claps in 8ths; a sustained note starts to rise in pitch | Increase subdivision; raise the register |
| 13–15 | The kick drops out; claps in 16ths; reverb grows | Remove the rest of the foundation; increase the wet signal |
| 16 | Everything stops except the reverb tail | Subtraction before the drop |
The foundation goes in two steps, bass first and kick later, so the build still has a pulse until near the end. Taking both out at bar 1 is also common, but then the other devices have to carry 16 bars on their own, which is a lot to ask of a clap.
Ways to release
Return of the kick and bass on a downbeat, ideally at a 16- or 32-bar boundary. The simplest release, and still the strongest.
Collapse: cut the reverb tails, close the filter and drop the subdivision at the same moment.
Arrival of the hook, or the hook’s first appearance over the full groove.
Partial release. Bring back the kick but hold back the bass, or keep the filter half closed. The listener gets some of what they waited for, and the full release is saved for a later drop.
Delayed release. Leave the downbeat of the drop empty, or bring the kick in a beat late. It works once or twice in a track. Do it in every drop and the audience learns the trick.
How much tension
The size of the build should match the size of what follows. A 16-bar build into a drop that is only slightly fuller feels like a false alarm. A 4-bar build into the biggest moment of the track feels rushed.
Tension also wears off. A build that stays at the same level for more than about 8 bars stops building, so if it runs longer, keep adding devices or step it up in stages.
1.7 Fatigue and judging a loop
A loop that is going to repeat for minutes has to be judged differently from a song idea. Your own ears also get less reliable the longer you work, so these tests are partly about protecting you from yourself.
The tests
The 20-loop test. Listen to the loop twenty times in a row at a moderate level, without touching anything. That is harder than it sounds. If you still want it at the end, the material is strong. If you start reaching for the mute button, note when.
The mute test. Mute each part in turn. If you don’t miss a part when it is muted, remove it or give it a job.
The one-sound test. For melodic hooks, play the riff on a plain piano. If it isn’t interesting there, a better sound won’t rescue it. For rhythmic or timbral hooks, where the sound is the hook (a one-note acid line, a filtered chord stab), mute the kick instead and check whether the part’s groove stands on its own.
The cold-ears test. Judge the loop again the next day, before you play anything else. Whatever bothers you in the first ten seconds is real.
Reading the result
When a loop gets dull tells you what is wrong with it.
| When it gets dull | What that means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Within the first few loops | The material is weak | Change the notes or the groove (Chapters 2, 6, 7) |
| After about 30 seconds | The loop has no micro or meso variation | Add feel variation and a turnaround bar (1.5) |
| After 2 or 3 minutes | It needs form | Plan macro variation and arrangement (1.5, Chapter 8) |
| Never, but it doesn’t go anywhere | Great loop, no track yet | Move to arrangement; stop adding to the loop |