Extensions, slash chords and one surprise per loop
Adding colour without breaking a chord’s function, and the borrowed chords that give a loop its signature.
5.5 Extensions and slash chords
Extensions add colour without changing what a chord does. Choose them by function:
| Function | Good extensions | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Major tonic | maj7, 6, add9, maj9, 6/9 | Cmaj9 |
| Minor tonic | m7, m9, m11 | Am9, Am11 |
| Predominant | m7, maj7, add9, m9 | Dm9, Fmaj7 |
| Dominant | 9, 13, 7sus4 | G9, G7sus4 |
A sus dominant pulls home gently instead of shouting, which suits house and soul. G7sus4 (G C D F) is the plain version; G9sus4 adds an A and is exactly an F major triad over a G in the bass, written F/G.
The semitone rule
An extension a semitone above a chord tone, sustained, sounds wrong: the note F held over a C major chord rubs against the chord’s E. A tone above sounds lush: the note D over C major. On major chords, use the sus4 or the #11 instead of a natural 11th.
Slash chords: rich chords from simple shapes
| Shape over bass | Resulting chord | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Em over C | Cmaj7 | Warm major tonic |
| G over C | Cmaj9 without the 3rd | Open, floating |
| F over G | G9sus4 | Soft dominant |
| C over E, G over B | First inversions | A bass that walks by step |
| Am over F | Fmaj7 | The “change the bass” trick from Chapter 1 |
5.6 Spice: one surprise per loop
One unexpected chord per progression is a signature. Two or three start to sound like a different genre. In order of reliability:
Minor iv in a major key (Fm in C major). Bittersweet and nostalgic; the most reliable borrowed chord there is. Best straight after IV: C – F – Fm – C.
bVI and bVII in major (Ab and Bb major chords in C major). Heroic and cinematic. bVI – bVII – I is a classic lift into a drop.
Major IV in minor (a D major chord in A minor). The Dorian brightening (Chapter 4).
Major V in minor (E or E7 in A minor). A strong pull home through the raised 7th, which also ends any modal feel (Chapter 4, 4.4).
Secondary dominants. Precede any chord with its own dominant to make it land harder: E7 – Am, A7 – Dm, D7 – G.
Deceptive cadence. V – vi instead of V – I: it delays home and buys another phrase.
Diminished passing chord. C – C#dim7 – Dm7: the bass climbs chromatically between two diatonic chords. A disco and gospel favourite.
Chromatic mediants. Roots a 3rd apart with the chord quality changed: C – E, C – Ab, Am – C#m. Cinematic; keep one shared note in the top voice to make the move smooth.