Swing, shuffle and microtiming
How much to delay the offbeats, which parts to swing, and where to place the snare.
2.3 Swing, shuffle and microtiming
Swing
Swing delays every second note of a subdivision. In electronic music it is usually measured the way the Akai MPC measured it: the percentage of the pair’s duration taken by the first note. At 50% the pair is dead straight; the higher the number, the later the second note.
| Swing amount | Feel | Typical use |
|---|---|---|
| 50% | Straight; machine-like | Techno, trance, EBM, many disco edits |
| 52–56% | A light lean, felt more than heard | House, deep house, nu-disco |
| 57–62% | A clear shuffle | Garage-influenced house, hip-hop, funk |
| 63–66% | Close to a triplet feel | UK garage, shuffle, swing jazz |
| Above 66% | Lopsided, drunken | Special effects; some broken beat and lo-fi |
Swing normally applies to 16ths in dance music (the “e” and “a” move later) and to 8ths in slower genres.
What to swing
Swing doesn’t have to apply to every part, and usually it shouldn’t. The classic approach is to keep the kick and the main snare or clap straight, and to swing the parts that live on 16th-note offbeats: hats, shakers, percussion and ghost notes. The groove comes from the straight foundation and the swung top pulling against each other.
Microtiming
Beyond swing, individual parts can sit slightly ahead of or behind the grid:
Ahead of the beat (a few milliseconds early): urgent, driving.
On the beat: neutral, machine-tight.
Behind the beat (a few milliseconds late): relaxed, heavy, “in the pocket”. A snare or clap slightly late is the quickest way to make a groove feel laid back.
J Dilla’s programming, with parts deliberately pulling against each other in time, turned this loose feel into a style that many producers have copied since.