Chapter 7 practice: diagnosis, Ableton Live 12, exercises and listening
A checklist for a melody that isn’t working, the Ableton Live 12 tools for this chapter, five exercises and a listening list.
7.8 Diagnosing a weak melody
When a melody isn’t working, the cause is usually one of these. Fix the first one you find before looking for the next.
| Symptom | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Hard to remember | Too many rhythms or ideas | Cut to two rhythm cells; make bar 3 repeat bar 1 |
| Aimless | No anchor note and no peak | Add a recurring anchor note (Chapter 6); give the phrase one peak |
| Dull | Static rhythm or exact repetition | Vary the note lengths; change the ending every fourth bar |
| Sounds wrong over the chords | Non-chord tones on strong beats | Move them off the beat, or change the chord |
| Strained | Range too wide | Keep it within an octave; move the widest leap |
| Fights the track | Same register as the pad or vocal | Move it an octave, or rest when the other part plays |
| Never feels finished | Every phrase ends away from the tonic, or every phrase ends on it | End question phrases away from home and answer phrases at home |
7.9 In Ableton Live 12
| Idea from this chapter | Tool in Live 12 | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Rhythm first | Rhythm generator on one note, then edit the pitches | Clip View, Generate tab |
| Drawing a contour | Shape generator: choose or draw a shape, then set rate and density | Clip View, Generate tab |
| Notes in key | Seed generator; Scale Mode with Fold to Scale | Clip View |
| Passing and neighbour tones | Connect and Ornament transformations | Clip View, Transform tab |
| Variations of a hook | Recombine transformation; duplicate the clip and change one thing | Clip View, Transform tab |
| Slicing a vocal | Simpler in Slice mode plays slices at their original pitch; to tune each slice, right-click the audio clip and choose Slice to New MIDI Track | Instruments; audio clip menu |
| Pitch and formants | Complex Pro warp mode with Formants; Auto Shift for pitch correction and formant shifting (Live 12.1 and later) | Clip View; Audio Effects |
| Learning a hook | Convert Melody to New MIDI Track | Right-click an audio clip |
7.10 Exercises
Exercise A: Rhythm first (30 minutes)
Over a 4-bar loop from Chapter 5, program a 2-bar rhythm on one note, using no more than two rhythm cells. Loop it until it grooves. Then assign pitches: chord tones on the downbeats, no more than five different notes, and one peak in bar 2.
Exercise B: Question and answer (30 minutes)
Extend the idea from Exercise A to 4 bars, with bar 2 ending away from home and bar 4 on a stable chord tone other than the tonic. Then extend it to 8 bars, changing only the ending, so that bar 8 resolves to the tonic. Write down which development device from 7.5 you used.
Exercise C: Same hook, new chords (20 minutes)
Keep your 8-bar hook and change the chords under its second statement: rotate the progression, or use tonic substitution (Chapter 5). Listen for which melody notes change function.
Exercise D: A chop hook (40 minutes)
Record or import a sung phrase of a few seconds. Slice it with Slice to New MIDI Track, keep three to five slices with clear vowels, and transpose each pad to a note in your key. Write a 2-bar chop hook using 7.4’s rules, then try it with and without formant correction.
Exercise E: Diagnose (20 minutes)
Take an old melody you were never happy with. Run it through the table in 7.8, fix the first problem you find, and only then decide whether it needs more.
7.11 Listening
For each, find the hook’s peak note, count its rhythm cells and name its phrase form.
Beethoven, “Ode to Joy” (Symphony No. 9). Almost entirely stepwise. The first phrase ends on the 2nd degree and the second, nearly identical, ends on the tonic: question and answer with a changed ending.
Avicii, “Levels” (2011). A synth hook over a four-chord loop in C# minor: i – bIII – bVII – bVI (C#m – E – B – A). Count how few pitches the hook uses and notice where its highest note falls.
Robin S., “Show Me Love” (StoneBridge remix, 1992). A sung vocal hook built on the repeated title line. The remix kept only the vocal and the kick drum from the original recording and built a new synth riff around them. Listen for how often the title line returns, and for what the riff does while the voice rests.
Jack Ü with Justin Bieber, “Where Are Ü Now” (2015). The flute-like lead that Skrillex called the “dolphin” is Bieber’s own voice, pitched two octaves up and distorted: a vocal chop used as the main hook.
Then take a hook you love and program it twice: once on its own pitches with every note the same length, and once with its rhythm on a single note. Notice what each version loses.